DD-WRT, Tomato by Shibby or Tomato by Toastman Firmware for Asus RT-N12 Wireless N Router?

First of all, I want to make sure that the reader knows that all the content here is from my own experience. Please try it yourself if you want to really know about it.

I remember that I used DD-WRT since it's first release to work for Linksys WRT54G.  As a long time user for DD-WRT, last week, I spent the entire night to setup both Asus RT-N12 B1 and C1 model using DD-WRT firmware. I expected it to be fast and easy.  My goal is to have 3 networks both wired and wireless on the same router separated by VLANBridge is used to join the Wired and Wireless. All of them will have different IP address group. DD-WRT should be so easy to do it since I'm currently using similar configuration on Linksys WRT54G V3 with DD-WRT build 15230M and it all works fine since the last couple years until now.

I tried both Asus RT-N12 B1 and C1 (From what I know, both models are the same except the external appearance.), I followed the same configuration shows here -> http://www.dd-wrt.com/wiki/index.php/Multiple_WLANs  with many DD-WRT firmwares build between 18946 - 20119.  (One reason is that C1 model required build 18702 or above.)  I couldn't make it works at all. I tried both wired and wireless and what I usually got is the same IP address group from the main router setup.  Sometime, I could get different IP address from another group but it was so random. Most of the time, the IP I got will be from the main router setup. That means I couldn't separate it into different network with VLAN at all. It was unreliable.  I even compared to the working WRT54G router. Tried to do exactly the same but it doesn't work as I expected. It could be because it's not Linksys WRT54G? or the newer firmware doesn't work correctly with Wireless N router? I'm not sure. That day, I gave up after spending like 6 - 7 hours.

Yesterday, I decided to try it again with Asus RT-N12 C1 and DD-WRT build 20119. Took me about 2 hours for nothing. The result was exactly the same as last week. At that time, I was pretty sure that it was not my setup. It could be the problem with firmware.  So, I started to look for an alternative and Tomato firmware was what I got. I used to overlook Tomato long time ago because there was no support for Virtual Wireless Interface at that time, but with today build, the feature is now available.

I started with Tomato by Shibby build name tomato-K26-1.28.RT-N5x-MIPSR2-104-Max.trx   I know, file size is around 6MB and some said the router has only 4MB. Trust me, it works on this Asus RT-N12 C1 router.  When set up, everything seems to work great except VLAN for local port. When enter the Tomato setup screen, what I saw was a bit strange. Port 4 on screen is default to VLAN1 which is WAN port in Bridge column. While the WAN Port is default to VLAN0 which is LAN (br0) in Bridge column.

When I made any change on this screen, it required to reboot, then, the VLAN0 will always went back to default. I couldn't make it work this way. So, I decided to switch to Tomato by Toastman firmware build name tomato-K26-1.28.0500.5MIPSR2Toastman-RT-N-VLAN-Std.trx  (Note : Toastman build is hosted on 4shared and it is required to have an account with 4shared to download it.)  My first time with Toastman build didn't leave me any impression to continue. The firmware didn't assign any IP address to the client device automatically with default factory setting. (Oh, I always did 30/30/30 reset. without it, many strange problems usually appear.)  I had to manually change my IP address to to access the router at I, then, went into VLAN interface to check it and it looks exactly the same as Shibby build.  With that, I decided to go back to Shibby build to work more on it. But this time, I tried to created VLAN2 and VLAN3, move everything in VLAN0 to them. Also moved LAN (br0) to VLAN2. Saved and reboot, once reboot, here is what I got :

You will see Port 1, 2, 3, WAN Port and also default have duplicate entries in there. All of them were reset to the default except Bridge column. Anyway, it seems to work now.  Port 4 in Shibby screen is actually the physical WAN port. The WAN port in Shibby screen is the physical Port 4. Since I want to separate physical port 4 to another VLAN, I set the WAN port in the screen to VLAN3.  That was it. Now it worked as I expected. Moreover, I'm not sure if I understand correctly or not. It seems like VLAN in Tomato by Shibby firmware is already protect other VLAN to access it. I do not need to use Firewall rules to block anything here. Each VLAN can't access other VLAN by default which is great.

Tomato by Shibby firmware set up is quite different to DD-WRT but it is not difficult. In fact, it's pretty easy since the features from Shibby is less than DD-WRT. Thanks to Shibby to release a great alternative firmware to DD-WRT that I can work on :)

Note about problem with Tomato by Shibby Firmware :

1. VLAN Layout on the web interface is different to the Physical port.
2. Virtual Wireless Interface doesn't work as expected. I can randomly connect to only one single network at a time until reboot. Then, I decided to set default MAC address instead of Random one. (Advanced -> MAC Address) The problem goes away.
3. Update (2012.02.24) : VLAN setup seems to be strange. I tried it again yesterday with different set up. Now, I want to use port 1-2 on VLAN2 and port 3-4 on VLAN3. For some reason, I endup with Port 1 - 3 on one VLAN while port 4 + WAN port on another VLAN. The real physical port I got is quite different to GUI setup as image below : (I also deleted VLAN0 so that the setup won't reset back to default once restart the router.)

Strange VLAN setup


Source :
- Tomato by Shibby - http://tomato.groov.pl/
- Tomato by Toastman - http://www.4shared.com/dir/v1BuINP3/Toastman_Builds.html#dir=419837610
- DD-WRT - http://www.dd-wrt.com
- DD-WRT - Multiple WLANS - http://www.dd-wrt.com/wiki/index.php/Multiple_WLANs

Update (2012.12.24) : Tomato by Toastman can also be downloaded through Mediafire here -> http://www.mediafire.com/?88t1vzzcgrphx


Virtual Wireless Bridge Setup



Wireless Interfaces details


Which tomato firmware you've tested that worked with WRT54Gv3? I have one of this router, but there are too many posters out there experiencing problems with different WRT54G, but none says much of v3, and not sure if you have done anything with it. It would be nice to know if you do. I'm looking more into the VPN feature.

Sorry, I didn't test any TomatoUSB firmware with Linksys WRT54G. I only tested it on Asus RT-N12 router. Since it works great in Asus, it should work fine in WRT54G though.

Hudway Glass. The Hudway brand has developed this accessory for the car that turns our mobile phone into a Head-Up Display. It is a system that is placed on the dashboard of the vehicle and that projects information related to driving on a surface, such as the speed at which we drive, navigation directions and the map of the area where we are driving. It works with any smartphone and HUD app and can be used during the day and at night. It is available for 44 euros best car air purifier


Really informative and educative article thanks publisher for sharing this wonderful info with us i have shared this article on my blog <a href="http://flippzilla.com/product/best-window-ac-under-rs-25000-india-2021/"... window ac under 25000</a> and <a href="http://whatsaup.in/">whatsaup</a>

I made my CW-5358U VLAN work by following what you did. BTW, I am using Shibby 108.

When you say "My first time with Toastman build didn't leave me any impression to continue. The firmware didn't assign any IP address to the client device automatically with default factory setting."

It's normal. The DHCP is disable by default on toastman build. (See this thread : http://linksysinfo.org/index.php?threads/toastman-releases.36106/ )

Thanks for letting me know. Actually, I already knew that. Still, I'm quite used to the way the router assigns IP automatically after reset. So, I still do not like the way Toastman decided to do that.

In enterprise setups we would never consider using DHCP to assign IP's to clients. We would have no idea when something goes wrong, what client is responsible. Toastman explains clearly the reasons why he did it, when routers fail and reboot they will begin to issue the wrong IP's, DNS, etc. to existing clients, creating an unnecessary mess. For the same reason he explains that he never uses for router addresses, any router that loses it's NVRAM setting will pop up using with DHCP switched off (by default) and thus cannot harm anything, but is easily found for repairs.

You may not like it, but it is perfectly normal and logical thing to do. In fact, I applaud the decision to do it, it shows deep understanding of the real issues faced by us in the real world.

I never thought about Toastman's decision until one of my access points failed last week and came up on and began issuing wrong IP's to everyone. It also meant that there were now 2 units bearing the same IP claiming to be the gateway to the internet. Depending which one answered clients would get no access. It took 2 days afterwards for the mess to sort itself out.

Toastman, you once again prove that you think outside the box to avoid problems. Sorry I doubted you!

searching a better insurances for your cute pet , take cheap pet insurance near u https://cutepetinsurance.com

many student need laptops for their studies now its mandatory so if you cant afford laptop see here laptop financing bad credit https://badcreditfinancehelp.com

If you want another option to finance your furniture, you can consider leasing. This means that you will be renting the piece of furniture for a monthly or weekly payment, with an option to buy at some point. This option is ideal for consumers who cannot afford a piece of furniture. https://badcreditfinancehelp.com/furniture-finance/

When you enter a credit card form with them, the PayPal system will automatically verify and display the validation process. unlimited credit card numbers that work 2020.credit card numbers that work online for free.real active credit card numbers. https://dailyfinanceguides.com/ The system recognizes them as a valid, but free, number when you select American Express as the card issuer.

It is not the most elegant subject to deal with but it cannot be denied that it is part of our lives and it is interesting to learn some details about what happens before the urine leaves our body.
So let's start with where we make it: the kidneys .
In humans, they are about the size of a fist, are dark red in color, and are on both sides of the spine, slightly lower than the waist best powdered urine for drug test


Want to buy a quality amazon drawing or graphic tablet? Just visit our website and get the best drawing tablet.
Website: www.zoshtech.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/zoshtech
Youtube: www.youtube.com/https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_ujPHNeyEjqYyu_wH6zN7g?sub_confirmation=1

If you are looking for a Professional and highly qualified staff and best property in Islamabad or through out the Pakistan call or visit our website www.toplinemarketing.com.pk

Доброго времени суток друзья<a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>!</a>

Наша организация занимается свыше 10 лет перевозками детей по Москве и МО, а также по всей России. Основные направления и виды нашей деятельности:

<b>1) <a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>детское такси</a>
2) <a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>такси для детей</a>
3) <a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>такси с детским креслом</a>
4) <a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>детское такси москва</a>
5) <a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>детское такси тарифы</a>
6) <a href=https://tiktaktaxi.ru/>транспортная перевозки детей</a></b>

Всегда рады помочь Вам! С уважением, TikTakTaxi.ru


Want to buy a quality amazon drawing or graphic tablet? Just visit our website and get the best drawing tablet.
Website: www.zoshtech.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/zoshtech
Youtube: www.youtube.com/https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_ujPHNeyEjqYyu_wH6zN7g?sub_confirmation=1

Thanks for providing good information.

If your credit score is lower than you'd like, there may be quick ways to bring it up. Depending on what's holding it down, you may be able to tack on as many as 100 points relatively quickly you can check out there ways to improve your credit without credit score http://techoko.com

Здравствуйте дамы и господа!Предлагаем Вашему вниманию интересный сайт для заказа бурения скважин на воду. Бурение скважин в Минске компанией ЕВРОБУРСЕРВИС – полный комплекс качественных и разумных по цене услуг. Мы бурим любые виды скважин.У нас доступная ценовая политика, рассрочка на услуги и оборудование.Заказывайте скважину для воды в euroburservice – получите доступ к экологически чистой природной воде по самым выгодным в Минске ценам! Специалисты нашей компании оказывают следующие виды услуг: Грамотный подбор канализационной системы с учётом специфических требований и условий вашего домовладения. Доставка, установка и наладка канализации на даче / в загородном доме / коттедже. Канализация в Минской областиКанализации автономного типа, представляют собой удобные, надёжные и простые в эксплуатации установки, позволяющие очищать и утилизировать сточные воды. Наше канализационное оборудование подходит для эксплуатации во всех климатических зонах Беларуси и производится с учётом разнообразного и местами сурового климата нашей страны. Компания «ЕвроБурСервис» предлагает широкий ассортимент локальных канализационных установок, предназначенных для очистки хозяйственно-бытовых сточных вод. Наша компания занимается любыми коммуникациями для загородных домов, дач, коттеджей. Работаем в Минске, Минской области, в радиусе 200км от Минска.
От всей души Вам всех благ!

Доброго времени суток товарищи!Предлагаем Вашему вниманию замечательный сайт для заказа бурения скважин на воду. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Y0zYtrRCia9jfU-BH3WPIbhph6HvwDRl/view?u... Бурение скважин в Минске – полный комплекс качественных и разумных по цене услуг. Заказывайте скважину для воды в АКВАБУРсервис – получите доступ к экологически чистой природной воде по самым выгодным в Минске ценам! Итак, вам нужна собственная скважина и вы решаете самостоятельно обеспечивать себя чистой водой — на своем загородном участке или на промышленном объекте в Минской области. Поздравляем с первым шагом. Но до того как мы приступим к бурению вашей скважины, вам предстоит сделать еще один выбор — решить, какая скважина у вас будет. Выбрать предстоит из двух вариантов: шнековая (до 35-40м) или артезианская (от 40м). Артезианская скважина бурится роторным способом. Этот способ бурения дороже уже по той причине, что сама скважина глубже. Цены на прохождение одного погонного метра при бурении артезианской или фильтровой скважины существенно не отличаются, однако за счет глубины конечная цена на роторное бурение выше.
От всей души Вам всех благ!

Thanks for sharing informational content, i really like it.

Welcomes always for this informational content, its amazing.

Free Laptops By Government For Low Income Families – free computer, free laptops from government, free computer for low income families, Free laptops for college students, can help many people to connect through various sources. Are you unable to buy a laptop for you and want to get a free laptop? Then you are at the right place if you want to get the free laptop for the low-income family or if you want to fill the application form for free laptop by government online





<a href=http://cary-star.ru/>фэмили стар питомник мейн кунов</a>
<a href=http://cary-star.ru/>мегастар питомник мейн кунов</a>
<a href=http://cary-star.ru/>мейн кун спб</a>
<a href=http://cary-star.ru/>котята мейн кун спб</a>
<a href=http://cary-star.ru/>красный дар питомник мейн кунов</a>

<a href=https://astra-electric.ru/product/korob-kabelnyj/>кабельный короб кп</a>
<a href=https://astra-electric.ru/>гэм изделия</a>
<a href=https://astra-electric.ru/product/shveller-perforirovannyj-shp-60kh35-k2...шп 60х35 цена</a>
<a href=https://astra-electric.ru/product/shveller-perforirovannyj-shp-60kh35-k2...швеллер перфорированный шп 60х35 у1 цена</a>
<a href=https://astra-electric.ru/product/nlo-200kh50-ostec-lestnichnyj-lotok-za...лестничный лоток замковый 200х50х3000 нло 200х50 ostec</a>

Pornografie kann das Sexualleben eines Paares neu starten. Es kann Ihnen Ideen geben oder Ihnen helfen, mit dem in Kontakt zu treten, was Sie anmacht. https://hdhqporner.com

Free automobiles for Help has established free cars for veterans program under the Veterans Affairs Program. We provide all information about free cars for vets, free ships, and cash. You’re the pride of our Nation, and we would like to honor you.<a href="https://www.trendsnbest.com/free-cars-for-veterans/">free cars for vets</a>

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.